We’ve seen some pretty nasty cemetery abuses in recent months, from Burr Oak to Arlington. Nancy in Texas tipped off the Death Reference Desk about a new bill in the U.S. House of Representatives that will hopefully prevent some anguish and anger in the not-quite-as-horrifically-egregious-as-outright-corpse-abuse-scandal arena but the still important — and affecting many more Americans — area of consumer protection.
Introduced on March 3 by Bobby Rush, D-IL, the Bereaved Consumer’s Bill of Rights Act of 2011 (H.R.900) will institute protections for consumers from “unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the provision of funeral goods or services” (OpenCongress.org).
According to the National Funeral Directors Association,
The bill would require the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to adopt a rule that would regulate all cemeteries, crematories and third-party sellers of funeral or burial services or merchandise to the public. VA cemeteries, cemeteries that conduct fewer than 25 burials per year, and cemeteries that are owned, managed and operated by a religious organization would be exempt from the rule. Religious cemeteries that are operated or managed by a for-profit funeral company and state and municipal cemeteries would not be exempt from the new rule. The requirements of the new rule would be similar to those that funeral homes must adhere to under the FTC Funeral Rule.
NFDA has long supported federal regulation of cemeteries, crematories and other sellers of funeral or burial goods or services because state laws are haphazard and inconsistent at best, and non-existent at worst. Moreover, the marketplace for funeral and burial goods and services has changed, giving consumers more choices than ever before. Consumers risk being subjected to the very practices that the FTC sought to prohibit when it promulgated the Funeral Rule in 1984.
Read the full text of the bill here. The Funeral Consumers Alliance chews through the legalese with some to-the-point bullets about what the bill will provide:
- Compel cemeteries to give consumers accurate prices before the sale
- Give cemetery consumers the right to buy only the goods and services they want; families will be able to buy markers, monuments, or grave vaults from less expensive retail vendors rather than being captive to the cemetery’s prices
- Bar cemeteries from forcing families to buy entire packages of goods or services, if the family wants to choose item by item
- Require cemeteries to disclose rules and regulations, and consumer rights, before the purchase
- Require cemeteries to keep accurate records of all burials sold, and where remains are interred, and to make those records available to regulators
- Bar cemeteries from lying about the law — claiming state laws “require” vaults to surround an in-ground casket, for example
The FCA is pretty darn excited about this (and so are we). See their site for links to contact state representatives about supporting this bill.
1 Response to The Bereaved Consumer’s Bill of Rights Act of 2011
Anonymous
September 11th, 2011 at 2:20 pm
The problem with this is it creates new rules without protecting consumers from things like what happened at tri-state crematory and from cemeteries removing remains and reselling the graves. If we are going to create new regulations they should be completely effective not only half complete.